Craving the best rice pudding in Brooklyn? This comforting, creamy dessert has won the hearts of locals—and one spot has risen above the rest. Voted by the community, this year’s winner for Best Rice Pudding in Brooklyn is known for its smooth texture, perfectly balanced sweetness, and rich, nostalgic flavor. Whether you like it classic or with a unique twist, this place serves a spoonful of comfort in every bite. Let’s dig into the best rice pudding in Brooklyn, as chosen by those who know it best.
2025: Brooklyn Voted Meze Best Rice Pudding!
Meze
6601 13th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 234 6393 – mezeny.com
Looking for a sweet treat? Meze serves the best rice pudding in Brooklyn, with their Rizogalo being a standout dessert that perfectly captures the essence of Greek sweetness. This creamy, indulgent dish is served with a generous sprinkle of cinnamon, elevating the rich, comforting texture of the pudding. Since opening in 2004, Meze has been a beloved staple in Dyker Heights, offering authentic Greek cuisine that keeps customers coming back for more. Made with the finest, freshest ingredients and imported Greek products, every dish, including the Rizogalo, is crafted with care and attention to detail. The rice pudding at Meze is the perfect end to a savory meal, offering a balance of sweetness and warmth that’s both satisfying and soothing. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, Meze’s Rizogalo is a must-try, showcasing why they serve the best Greek desserts in Brooklyn.
2024: Brooklyn Voted Off Shore Diner Best Rice Pudding!
Off Shore Diner
7822 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 921-59009 – offshorediner.com
In a borough full of sweet treats, you can’t sleep on rice pudding. Brooklyn’s Off Shore Diner offers the best rice pudding in the city, delighting customers with its creamy texture and comforting flavors. The classic dessert is lovingly prepared using a family recipe that’s been passed down through generations. The perfectly cooked rice is blended with rich, velvety milk and a hint of vanilla, then gently simmered to achieve a luscious consistency. The pudding is finished with a dusting of cinnamon and a sprinkle of golden raisins for added sweetness. Off Shore Diner’s rice pudding is a true treat for the senses.