There is no shortage of famous pizza spots in Brooklyn, from Bay Ridge to Williamsburg. Read on to see which pizzerias were voted Best Pizza in Brooklyn by voters from 2019 to present.
2026: Brooklyn Voted Pizza Wagon Best Pizza Slice!
Pizza Wagon
8610 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 836-5725 – pizzawagonofbrooklyn.com
A single slice tells you almost everything about a pizza place, and Pizza Wagon has had decades to get that test right. The pizzeria traces its roots to 1966 and has built lasting loyalty by doing the essentials well: crisp crust, balanced sauce, real cheese, and a neighborhood-shop feel that never goes out of style. Whether customers come in for a quick plain slice or something more elaborate, the strength of the place is consistency. Pizza Wagon understands that the slice is the résumé.