There is no shortage of famous pizza spots in Brooklyn, from Bay Ridge to Williamsburg. Read on to see which pizzerias were voted Best Pizza in Brooklyn by voters from 2019 to present.
2025: Brooklyn Voted Bay Ridge Pizza Best Pizza! (Tie)
Bay Ridge Pizza
7704 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 680-5405 – bayridgepizza.com
Bay Ridge Pizza serves the best pizza in Brooklyn, and with 40 years of dedication to quality, it’s no wonder they’ve become a neighborhood favorite. Every pizza is made fresh, using only the finest ingredients, ensuring that each slice is bursting with flavor. Whether you opt for a classic cheese pizza or choose from their wide range of specialty pies, you’re in for a treat. Their menu also includes heroes, hearty entrees, and main courses, perfect for a satisfying meal with family or friends. For those with dietary preferences, Bay Ridge Pizza offers whole wheat pasta and gluten-free pizza options, so everyone can enjoy a delicious meal. Pizzas come in various sizes—mini, small, large, or Sicilian—making it easy to satisfy any craving. Celebrating four decades in business, Bay Ridge Pizza remains a top choice for those who value quality, taste, and a family-friendly dining experience.
2025: Brooklyn Voted Pizza Wagon Best Pizza! (Tie)
Pizza Wagon
8606 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 836-5725
Pizza Wagon in Bay Ridge, NY, is a beloved neighborhood staple that’s been family-owned and operated since 1966! Nestled along bustling 5th Avenue, this classic pizzeria has been serving up timeless New York slices for generations. Known for its perfectly crisp thin crust, tangy sauce, and gooey, golden cheese, it’s a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The menu keeps it simple — just the essentials, done right. The cozy interior offers seating, allowing you to sit down and savor your slice in an old-school, no-frills setting. Pizza Wagon isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel — it’s just proudly doing what it does best: delivering consistently great, traditional pizza. If you’re in Bay Ridge and craving a slice of authentic Brooklyn, this place is a must. Cash only, so come prepared!
2024: Brooklyn Voted Pizza Wagon Best Pizza!
Pizza Wagon
8606 5th Avenue, Brooklyn
(718) 836-5725
Many a pizza place in Brooklyn (and, to be honest, the entire city) has vyed for the title of the best pizza spot in town. But there can only be one best pizza place. Brooklyn’s Pizza Wagon is renowned for serving the best pizza in the borough, offering a delightful dining experience in its charming Bay Ridge location. Pizza Wagon excels in crafting classic New York-style pizza, showcasing a perfectly crisp crust, zesty tomato sauce, and a generous layer of high-quality cheese. What truly sets Pizza Wagon apart is its creative range of toppings, providing something for every taste. Whether you’re in the mood for a traditional slice or one topped with unique and delicious combinations, Pizza Wagon delivers an array of flavors that keep customers coming back for more. Additionally, their Sicilian pies are a must-try, with a thick, airy crust that’s crisp on the outside and delightfully soft on the inside.
2023: Brooklyn Voted Bay Ridge Pizza Best Pizza!
Bay Ridge Pizza
7704 5th Avenue, Brooklyn
(718) 680-5405 – bayridgepizza.com
We all know Brooklynites are serious about pizza. Everyone has their go-to spot that they’ll defend any day of the week, and the favorite that most can agree on is Bay Ridge Pizza. This pizzeria came out on top likely for its wide selection of toppings. The popular pizza joint has perfected its regular cheese and pepperoni pies, so you can be confident about ordering something more adventurous, such as the pies with pineapple, shrimp, or jalapeño toppings. And when you just can’t decide on a classic topping, there’s the Bay Ridge Special: pizza with meatballs, onions, peppers, mushroom, pepperoni, and sausage. Folks also visit the beloved establishment for its taco pizza, vegetarian pies, and delicious Sicilian slices. There’s nothing a pizza lover can’t get when they order at Bay Ridge Pizza!
2022: Brooklyn Voted Bay Ridge Pizza Best Pizza!
Bay Ridge Pizza
77-04 5th Ave
(718) 680-5407 – bayridgepizza.com
We all know Brooklynites are serious about pizza. Everyone has their go-to spot that they’ll defend any day of the week, and the favorite that most can agree on is Bay Ridge Pizza. This pizzeria came out on top likely for its wide selection of toppings. The popular pizza joint has perfected its regular cheese and pepperoni pies, so you can be confident about ordering something more adventurous, such as the pies with pineapple, shrimp, or jalapeno toppings. And when you just can’t decide on a classic topping, there’s the Bay Ridge Special: pizza with meatballs, onions, peppers, mushroom, pepperoni, and sausage. Folks also visit the beloved establishment for its taco pizza, vegetarian pies, and delicious Sicilian slices. There’s nothing a pizza lover can’t get when they order at Bay Ridge Pizza!
2021: Brooklyn Voted Graziella’s Best Pizza!
Graziella’s
232 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 789-5663 – www.graziellasmenu.com
Brooklyn is known for its pizza, which means the fight for best slice in the borough is some pretty steep competition. But there is a clear winner amongst cheesy pizza-loving Brooklynites — Graziella’s on Vanderbilt is the one to beat. At home in Fort Greene since 2004, Graziella’s has made a name for itself for its quality-fresh ingredients and generous portions. Its famous pizzas start with Italian flour and tomatoes, then bake in a 100 percent wood-burning brick oven. With more than a dozen pizzas to choose from (reds and white, oh my! — and all of them available in gluten-free), there’s something for every pizza lover at Graziella’s!
2020: Brooklyn Voted Bay Ridge Pizza Best Pizza!
Bay Ridge Pizza
7704 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 680-5405 – www.bayridgepizza.com
Grab a regular or sicilian slice of pizza at Bay Ridge Pizza Restaurant and Caterers, where all of their dishes are homemade and prepared with the freshest ingredients. Choose from a variety of pizza choices or heroes for lunch, or enjoy dinner with friends or family dining on a selection of entrees and main courses. Bay Ridge Pizza Restaurant also provides catering services for special occasions with a selection of pasta dishes, seafood dishes, vegetable dishes, salads, panini platters and wine. For a sweet dessert, ask about their cheesecake, carrot cake and tiramisu. They also now offer all types of fruit, cheese and olive platters.
2019: Brooklyn Voted Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza & Trattoria Best Pizza!
Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza & Trattoria
7902 3rd Ave.
(718) 439-6993 – www.giacomopizza.com
Out of all the amazing pizzerias in Brooklyn, Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza and Trattoria stands alone as the borough’s champion of cheese, dough and sauce. Their pizza is the main event and will wow you with a taste of Italy. Giacomo and his family have been in the Restaurant/pizzeria business for over 40 years. You can enjoy so many kinds of amazing toppings on your pizza, and the experience will have you coming back for more.
2017: Brooklyn Voted Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza & Trattoria Best Pizza!
Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza & Trattoria
7902 Third Avenue. (718) 439-6993. www.giacomopizza.com
Pizza lovers make this a must-taste. Giacomo’s Wood Fired Pizza & Trattoria serves up some of the best slices and pies in Bay Ridge. Along with their stellar reputation and years of faithful service to the Bay Ridge community, Giacomo’s prides itself on offering the service and feel of fine dining in a casual, family-friendly atmosphere.