Brooklyn is home to a vibrant and diverse food scene, and Mexican food is no exception. In fact, Brooklyn is home to some of the best Mexican food in the country. Serving up the most delicious al pastor tacos, carnitas, nachos, and guacamole you’ve ever tasted, you won’t be disappointed at the Best of Brooklyn reader-approved best Mexican restaurant in Brooklyn.
2024: Brooklyn Voted Alma Negra Best Mexican Restaurant!
Alma Negra
494 4th Ave, Brooklyn
(917) 909-0339 – almanegranyc.com
Are you looking for a Mexican restaurant with a modern feel and welcome vibe? Look no further than Alma Negra, a top-notch Mexican restaurant in Park Slope. Alma Negra’s menu — curated by executive chef Fermin Teco — is packed with fresh, locally sourced ingredients that result in some seriously tasty dishes. Their tacos are a highlight — loaded with flavorful meats and fresh veggies — and their guacamole is always a crowd-pleaser. Other favorites include their enchiladas, chiles rellenos, and creative fusion dishes that put a modern twist on classic Mexican flavors. Plus, the staff at Alma Negra are friendly and attentive, making you feel right at home. And who could forget the margaritas?
2023: Brooklyn Voted Chela Best Mexican Restaurant!
Chela
408 5th Avenue, Brooklyn
(718) 701-1891 – chelaparkslope.com
Chelain is a Mexican restaurant located in the heart of Brooklyn that has gained a reputation for its authentic cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the delicious flavors and generous portions of traditional Mexican dishes, such as tacos al pastor, enchiladas, and guacamole. The restaurant is known for its friendly and attentive staff, who make sure that every guest feels right at home. Chelain’s colorful decor and vibrant ambiance only add to the overall dining experience. Whether it’s a casual weeknight dinner or a weekend celebration, Chelain in Brooklyn is a must-visit spot for anyone looking to satisfy their craving for delicious Mexican food.
2022: Brooklyn Voted Chela Best Mexican Restaurant!
Chela
409 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 701-1894 – chelaparkslope.com
You don’t have to go south of the border to find an authentic Mexican meal — just head over to Chela! This restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy delicious Mexican food. Chela’s streamlined menu only has the best of the best, so you are guaranteed to make a tasty choice that will tantalize your taste buds each and every time you dine there. From fresh made guacamole (with three different spice options) and nachos to costillas tacos and chilaquiles, there is truly something for everyone — there are even vegan tacos for those living a plant-based lifestyle to munch on. Be sure to swing by and enjoy one of Chela’s cocktails while you dine!
2021: Brooklyn Voted Chela Best Mexican Restaurant!
Chela
408 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 701-1894 – www.chelaparkslope.com
You don’t have to go south of the border to find an authentic Mexican meal — just head over to Chela! This restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy delicious Mexican food. Chela’s streamlined menu only has the best of the best, so you are guaranteed to make a tasty choice that will tantalize your taste buds each and every time you dine there. From fresh made guacamole (with three different spice options) and nachos to costillas tacos and chilaquiles, there is truly something for everyone — there are even vegan tacos for those living a plant-based lifestyle to munch on. Be sure to swing by and enjoy one of Chela’s cocktails while you dine!
2020: Brooklyn Voted Chela Best Mexican Restaurant!
Chela
408 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 701-1894 – www.chelaparkslope.com
Brothers Felipe and Carlos Arellano began their culinary career as young children in Oaxaca, Mexico. At the age of four, they were already making ceviches and learning the art of developing flavor using salt, acidity, and local produce. As young adults, Carlos and Felipe packed their bags and migrated to California to break into the action on the bustling restaurant scene in Los Angeles. They worked in a variety of restaurants on the West Coast before deciding to come to the East Coast, settling in NYC where they worked as chefs at the famous Rosa Mexicano Restaurant. After working there for several years, they were approached to join the successful boutique chain of restaurants, Besito Mexican, where they have worked for the past decade as the executive chef and executive sous chef respectively. The brothers are excited to bring their love and passion of all foods Mexican to Park Slope.
2019: Brooklyn Voted Chela Best Mexican Restaurant!
Chela
408 5th Ave
(718) 701-1891 – www.chelaparkslope.com
Brothers Felipe and Carlos Arellano began their culinary career as young children in Oaxaca, Mexico. At the age of 4, they were already making ceviches and learning the art of developing flavor using salt, acidity, and local produce. As young adults, Carlos and Felipe packed their bags and migrated to California to break into the action on the bustling restaurant scene in Los Angeles. They worked in a variety of restaurants on the West Coast before deciding to come the Best Coast, settling in NYC where they worked as chefs at the famous Rosa Mexicano Restaurant. After working there for several years, they were poached to join the successful boutique chain of restaurants, Besito Mexican, where they have worked for the past decade as the Executive Chef and Executive Sous Chef respectively. The brothers are excited to bring their love and passion of all foods Mexican at Chela.
2017: Brooklyn Voted Calexico Best Mexican Restaurant!
Calexico
645 Manhattan Avenue (347) 763-2129 www.calexico.net
Named after a small town on the border of California and Mexico, Calexico is a family-owned and operated eatery that – with a total of seven locations nationwide – excels in top-notch Mexican cooking. What started as a food cart in SoHo, selling tacos and burritos for a few bucks, quickly grew to become the establishment it is today, including its famed Greenpoint location, which takes the cake for best Mexican in the borough. Its menu boasts all the favorites – from guacamole and carne fries to burritos and quesadillas – to fun and festive dishes like Calexico’s sizzling fajitas. All that, coupled with its tremendous customer service, helps make it the best Mexican restaurant in the borough.