Craving the best milkshake in Brooklyn? Whether you’re into classic vanilla, rich chocolate, or over-the-top creations piled high with toppings, one local spot has earned the title of milkshake royalty. Voted by the community, this year’s winner for Best Milkshake in Brooklyn is known for its creamy texture, bold flavors, and picture-perfect presentation. It’s the kind of shake that hits the spot every time. Let’s dive into the best milkshake in Brooklyn, as chosen by those who know great shakes best—Brooklyn locals.
2025: Brooklyn Voted Parkview Diner Best Milkshake!
Parkview Diner
2939 Cropsey Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 333-9400
Parkview Diner serves the best milkshake in Brooklyn, offering a rich, creamy treat that’s the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth. Their milkshakes are made with high-quality ice cream and blended to perfection, creating a smooth, thick consistency that’s indulgent with every sip. Whether you choose classic chocolate, creamy vanilla, or fruity strawberry, each flavor is packed with bold, authentic taste that’s sure to please. The milkshakes are topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, adding a decadent finishing touch to this irresistible dessert. Whether you’re pairing it with a meal or enjoying it on its own, Parkview Diner’s milkshakes are the ultimate comfort drink, always refreshing and satisfying. With their commitment to quality and flavor, it’s no surprise that Parkview Diner is known for serving the best milkshakes in Brooklyn, leaving customers coming back for more every time.
2024: Brooklyn Voted Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain Best Milkshake!
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
513 Henry St, Brooklyn
(718) 522-6260 – brooklynfarmacyandsodafountain.com
What makes a great milkshake? Is it the creamy consistency, the richness of the flavor, or perhaps the nostalgic rush it brings with every sip? At Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain, the answer encompasses all these elements and more. Nestled within the vibrant streets of Brooklyn, New York, this 1920s apothecary store turned soda fountain is renowned for crafting the finest milkshakes in the borough. Originally Longo’s Drugs, this family-owned establishment underwent a revival in 2010. While the exterior of 513 Henry Street may have appeared weathered, within, a time capsule awaited—a testament to its storied past. Amongst the remnants of decades past, the idea of a modern-day soda fountain emerged, blending old-world charm with contemporary flair. Today, Brooklyn Farmacy and Soda Fountain stands as a beacon of nostalgia, where the art of crafting the perfect milkshake is a cherished tradition. With every creamy swirl and satisfying sip, patrons are transported to a simpler time, relishing in the delight of Brooklyn’s finest milkshake experience.
2023: Brooklyn Voted BurgerFi Best Milkshake!
BurgerFi
719 86th Street, Brooklyn
(718) 836-0836 – burgerfi.com
BurgerFi, the eatery in Dyker Heights, has been leaving customers delighted with their delicious and refreshing shakes. With a wide range of flavors to choose from, customers can savor the rich, creamy and thick shakes that are made from the freshest ingredients. The staff is always friendly and helpful, making the ordering process quick and seamless. Whether it’s a hot summer day or a cold winter evening, BurgerFi’s milkshakes are the perfect treat to satisfy any craving. With their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, BurgerFi has become a go-to destination for milkshake lovers in the area. Anyone in the mood for a satisfying milkshake experience should definitely give BurgerFi a try.